Groundwater; an untapped resource?

💧What is groundwater 



This video provides an introductory insight into the topic discussed in the blog. 

Michelle Williams the Dean of the faculty at the Harvard TH Chan School of Public health wrote an emotive piece for the Financial Times with the crisis narrative around climate change as one of the main themes to Africa’s food and water security article. One of the solutions she proposes which she believes has not been utilised effectively is groundwater.

"Expanding that (Amount of groundwater used) and investing in desalination plants could strengthen the region’s resilience against droughts and other climate shocks; most countries in Africa have enough groundwater to last decades, even if rainfalls diminish”.

Figure 1: Tweet from the BGS on groundwater


The tweet above evokes the same message as the article yet groundwater is being perceived as the solution to drought, however the complexities of groundwater means that whilst there are groundwater reserves in African countries I argue 50 years worth of water is a false statement as sole use of this resource can lead to the same consequences of the green revolution in Asia (John and Babu, 2021). Whilst 1% of the cultivated land in Africa is irrigated using groundwater with 80% being in North Africa, the extraction process of groundwater change the aquifer once overexploitation occurs and alters the water table (Siebert et al., 2010) .

Lets debunk that last statement by Michelle on most countries in Africa having enough groundwater to last decades.

1)      Different depth groundwater storages

No two groundwater aquifers are the same and here depth and geology play a key role in the accessibility of the resource. Differing geologies for example sedimentary basins which are commonly found in north Africa have the depth of 50m with weathered crystalline rock found in areas of equatorial Africa. These varying depths and differing geologies means the extraction process will look very different depending on the aquifer (Taylor et al., 2019). The amount of water also differs based on these factors as crystalline basement rock tend to contain the least amount of storage (Nanteza et al., 2016). A small storage of groundwater usually leads to small community handpumps for small scale irrigation plots or for domestic use but are unsuitable for large amounts of extraction. The infrastructure required for small volume aquifers are much smaller scale compared to large groundwater storages which are much deeper and usually much more difficult to access. This will require specialist drilling equipment which increases the cost of exploiting these resources (Alan et al., 2013).

2)      Recharge rates

Again no two groundwater aquifers have the exact same recharge rates. Previous studies highlight how many African countries with low recharge rates possess substantial groundwater storage whereas aquifers with low storage experience a high as well as regular recharge (Edmunds, 2012). This brings the question of sustainability into the matter. Is it sustainable to extract groundwater when it is known the groundwater resource took around 5000 years to recharge? The simple answer is no, this is not sustainable. However with issues of extended dry seasons due to climate change this may be an attractive solution for politicians in the short term.

Figure 2: Source (McDonald, 2021)


Figure 2 highlights the long term average of groundwater recharge. This particular study highlights the spatial differentiations of groundwater recharge in the African continent. From the graph it is evident that recharge is not detected in major sites in parts of north and south Africa (red dots). Semi-arid and arid regions have some source of groundwater recharge although this did not occur on an annual basis whilst in the sub-humid and humid regions recharge was occurring annually.

Whilst mapping is useful in visualising the recharge rates based on region, it requires on the ground data collection and with groundwater changing and being influenced by factors such as pollution, contamination, over-extraction, recharge data needs to be collected over a long period of time which can prove to be a challenge for funding extensive (Edmunds, 2012).

Returning back to the FT article yes, the statistics paint a simplistic picture; if there is an ample amount of groundwater aquifers in the African continent why is the resource not exploited? However, the statistics show one side of the story with an estimate of how much groundwater is in Africa, without highlighting the complexities of groundwater extraction, geology, depth, recharge and social factors to do with contamination, infrastructure which are playing a significant role in the management of this resource.

Solutions

One of the solutions to groundwater management is long term research into the groundwater aquifers. Analysing the changes in aquifers based on extraction and recharge can help make informed decisions on estimating how much extraction of the resource can be possible without undermining sustainability. Projects such as UPGro have been working on building the scientific knowledge of African groundwater storage and working with communities who will ultimately be using the resource. The aim was to recognise that different areas may have different uses and requirements for groundwater and being able to provide communities with different scenarios and options for future extraction allows them to make the decisions based on their current and future needs. The ultimate goal is to not have a repeat of the green revolution in Asia where groundwater was used in an unsustainable manner which lead to unhealthy aquifers and left the agricultural economy reliant on groundwater for irrigation.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The 'Biblical' famine

Image
  What was the cause of the 1983-85 famine in Ethiopia Figure 1: Bob Geldof in Ethiopia at the forefront of a new celebrity fundraising effort, sparked by the BBC’s report on Ethiopia’s famine. Source: The Guardian  Contrary to the what the papers and aid commercials reported about the Ethiopian famine, the ‘Biblical’ famine was not simply due to a drought and a late rainy season but rather do due a combination of natural and man-made factors. The components being drought, environmental deterioration such as soil erosion, population growth, underinvestment in agriculture, government policies and civil war . Whist drought is the main cause of famine the Ethiopian civil war and governmental politics played a significant role. In 1974 the overthrowing of emperor Haile Selassie was overthrown and a new military group called the Derg began to run the country. Whilst this happened in 1974 about ten years before the famine it is important to note how political instability can impa...
Read more

What's an economy without water?

Image
📈Reading beyond trend lines The last blog ended with the the figure below showing precipitation and GDP seeming to have a relationship. The question posed was are African economies reliant on rainfall. The main aim of this blog is to recognise that most African countries agriculture is a large part of the GDP for example  37.57% of Ethiopias GDP  constitutes of agriculture however, rainfall cannot be deemed as the single most significant factor causing economic downturns and in fact political climates may be playing a significant role in the economies. The example of Zimbabwe will be used to demonstrate this point.  Figure 1: Data sourced from The World Bank . Chart made in Flourish.  GDP as a political tool  The IPCC reported that rainfall plays a significant role in reducing growth in Africa. Whilst rainfall is having impacts on GDP to a certain extent this is being used to cover up for poor governance in Zimbabwe. In 2000 the government of Zimbabwe...
Read more

Reflections

Over the course of these blogs it is apparent that issues surrounding water and food are anything but simple but rather a complex nexus between resource and man.  Main takeaways  1) Water is inherently political and is used to gain power or maintain control. As water is the most valuable resource  2) Look beyond the resource. The exploration of groundwater highlighted how large amount of aquifers does not necessarily mean an abundance of water or result in easy extraction process. There has to be a human face to the physicality of groundwater. issues such as infrastructure and research must be considered into the discussions around groundwater  3) Governance and politics are having great impact on water management but is being mistaken for a water availability or lack of rainfall issue.  Thanks for reading!
Read more